11 Top Shops for Buffalo-Themed Gifts

By Lindsay Riggs

Published on | Last Updated

Native, ex-pat, local or aspiring Buffalonian – folks that love Buffalo say it proudly. From wearing Buffalo tees, hanging Buffalo ornaments on the Christmas tree, decorating the house in 716 memorabilia, to sipping your morning coffee from a Buffalo mug, there’s no shortage of ways to express Buffalove. And with holidays quickly approaching, whether you live near or far, you can give the gift of Buffalo this holiday season when you buy at these shops filled with presents and goodies for all the Buffalovers out there:

Buffalo ShopCraft, 773 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo

You can find creative products and designs from local artists throughout this shop which boast ornaments, jewelry, wall art, body products, apparel, and small gifts with a big Buffalo flair.

Shop online: buffaloshopcraft.com

Oxford Pennant, 731 Main St, Buffalo

Fly your Buffalo flag proud! Expertly printed and custom designed pennants that celebrate everything are available at Oxford Pennant’s Main Street shop. Oh, and there’s tons of apparel and locally made products to browse, too!

Shop online: oxfordpennant.com

Nest in the Village, 5436 Main St, Williamsville

Filled with Buffalo-centric home goods and more, your house will adorned in Queen City beauty with a Buffalo pillow or Chris Hyzy’s ‘B is for Buffalo’ book! Perfect gifts for the host or even yourself.


The BFLO Store, McKinley Mall, Eastern Hills Mall, Boulevard Mall, Galleria Mall & Canalside

This is the Mecca of Buffalo gift giving! There’s literally no other place to find all Buffalo-themed everything.

Shop online: bfloshop.com

Pasteurized Tees, 795 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo

For the person who feels most comfortable in a soft, well-fitting t-shirt, you can find creative, playful Buffalo tees here. And with speedy printing, you can even create your own design to show your Buffalo roots!

Shop online: pasteurizedtees.com

Sunshine + Bluebirds, Walden Galleria Mall, 798 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo & 4125 North Buffalo Rd, Orchard Park

With two locations, Sunshine + Bluebirds has all the gifts for the ladies. Featuring Buffalove jewelry and the very popular Buffalo spirit jersey, you’ll look good sporting some hometown pride!

Shop online: sunshineandbluebirds.com

My Cuzin Vintage, 168 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo

While not exclusively a Buffalo-themed vintage shop, My Cuzin Vintage stocks an incredible selection of retro Bills, Sabres and Buffalo apparel, merchandise, and more. It’s like walking into your childhood closet!

Shop online: mycuzinvintage.com

Photo by Buffalo Made Co.

Buffalo Made Co., 110 Genesee St, Buffalo

This is not your typical Buffalo apparel. Designer Rob Hopkins makes Buffalo gear with an edge, so you can rep your city and look incredible doing it.

Shop online: buffalomade.co

Photo by Buffalo in a Box

Online Retailers:

Buffalo2U, Buffalo2U.com

Build and customize your own Buffalo-themed gift box for any and all Buffalovers in your life – whether here at home or anywhere across the US.

Everything Buffalo, EverythingBUF.com

For the sports lover, Everything Buffalo keeps a fresh stock of Bills t-shirts, merchandise and accessories for showing your Bills Mafia pride on gameday.

Buffalo in a Box, buffaloinabox.com

Buffalo in a Box is your go-to source for anyone needing a fix for Buffalo food. Shipping Buffalo-made goodies and condiments anywhere, this is the one spot to stock up on Anchor Bar, Chiavetta’s, and Loganberry products.

Lindsay Riggs headshot

Lindsay Riggs

Lindsay Riggs is 1/2 of the social influencer blog Buffalovebirds. Lindsay, her husband Beau, and baby Chloe explore WNY to find new things to do as a family, great places to eat, and where to shop.